Cheat Day: Supper Heroes in Huntsville, AL

Supper Heroes in Huntsville, AL

Let’s play an analogy game: _______ is to my wife as Star Wars is to me.

If your answer was either superheroes or Superman, then you won the game. Congrats! With that in mind, it should come as no surprise to you that the recent theatrical release of Man of Steel had my wife in a tizzy.

In order to celebrate, she took a day off work and had herself a themed outing for her favorite muscle-bound boyscout. We bought IMAX tickets, got in an early run at a local park (while listening to and humming the John Williams theme from Superman the Movie, no less), and then headed to Supper Heroes in Huntsville, AL, the most wonderfully geektastic restaurant you can imagine.

We walk in the door, and I immediately start to smile. There are superhero posters everywhere, decoupage tabletops made from comic book panels, hero-logos painted onto the light fixtures, Silver Age comics as wall decorations, and even the menus are printed as pulpy dot-matrix throwbacks.

In other words, we were in geek heaven.

Bam! Pow! Zot!…To Our Diets

Keep in mind, though, this was a pre-planned cheat day. We knew going in that this restaurant isn’t full of health foods. You won’t find organic sprouted breads, kale and quinoa salads, or even turkey burgers.

Supper Heroes Huntsville Menu 1

You’re going to find cheesy, cajun waffle fries, Swiss Roll milkshakes, and 80/20 ground beef

And you’re going to love every bite of it.

After having a good run that morning and skipping lunch in order to eat at Supper Heroes, we were pretty much starving when we arrived. Which was a good thing.

We didn’t bother ordering an appetizer because our meals were going to be so extravagantly decadent: I ordered the Used Car Salesman (a traditional cheeseburger with all the fixins) and my wife ordered the Luchadore (a taco-style burger with guacamole, pico, and all that yummy spicy goodness). Both orders came with waffles fries and coleslaw.

Supper Heroes Huntsville Menu

The fries were excellent, and I was horribly tempted to order a second serving, the coleslaw was good, but neither of us are slaw people, so it was left largely uneaten, an the main courses–the gigantic, honkin’ burgers–were as delectable as any I’ve had. For what it’s worth, my burger was better than any I’ve ever had at Five Guys, and I think those are primo.

Jennifer adored hers, too, and she commented on how cool it was that the burger was split in half and served in two tortillas, like a taco. She noted that it was spicy enough to be flavorful, but never too hot to eat and make her want to gulp down a fire-extinguisher–which is exactly where a burger called The Luchadore should sit.

And even though we didn’t try it, there is a daily flavor of Kool-aid on the menu. Seriously. Who didn’t grow up with Batman: The Animated Series and a glass of grape Kool-aid after school? Talk about a throwback. My wife was so excited to see Kool-aid on the menu that next time we go (and I can guarantee that there will be a next time), we will definitely be snagging that nomtastic delight, despite the sugar.

Dialogue Balloons

The staff was great, too. Our waitress not only kept a good eye on our food and drink, but she also took particular pride in the comic collection on the walls, told us how she had decoupaged a particular tabletop with the theme of “intensity,” and let us know that she was the one who painted the logos and symbols on the lights above our heads.

After we were finished, she gave us a tour of the place, including the Batman-themed waiting area–that she affectionately called the Batcave–they use when the restaurant is busy. It was awesome.

Jennifer at Supper Heroes in Huntsville

We talked about comics, movies, Joss Whedon, Star TrekStar Wars, J.J. Abrams, fitness, mainstream geek culture, and even found out that the next day was Super Saturday, a tongue-in-cheek celebration of a particular Superman-hating employee’s birthday. It was refreshing to be able to go into a restaurant and feel like you actually get to know the staff. We even had a conversation about where to buy the best geeky T-shirts. #awesomesauce

Probably the best part, though, was that the 1980s The Incredible Hulk was playing on the TV behind us. I immediately recognized the episode as the one where Thor shows up, and I made sure that my wife watched as the Norse god was summoned through some wonderfully cheesy lightning effects. I mean, I remember watching that particular episode over and over again on an old, dubbed VHS tape when I was a kid. It was my favorite of the whole seres. Seeing it on the TV in Supper Heroes was a real treat I never could have anticipated.

Same Bat-time, Same Bat-channel

If it isn’t completely obvious, we’re enamored with Supper Heroes. I’m so happy that geek culture is becoming so prevalent that a restaurant like this can thrive, even in a stereotypically non-geeky region like the South (though to be fair, Huntsville is a pretty hoppin’ geek/tech center).

B.J. at Supper Heroes in Huntsville

Awesomely geektastic theme aside, Supper Heroes is a good restaurant. The food was incredibly high quality, the prices were more than reasonable (both of us ate until we were stuffed for well under twenty bucks), and the menu was filled with neato items that you just don’t see every day (did I mention they had a Swiss Roll milkshake? I want to try it so bad.)

I know that the next time we’re planning a cheat day where we have fun while splurging on really good food without worrying about calories, it will probably be at Supper Heroes. And in all honesty, I can almost guarantee that the atmosphere that the restaurant promotes has made it so that Huntsville will become our go-to city for superhero movies.

I mean, we had such an awesome superhero theme day for Man of Steel, why wouldn’t we want to repeat that over and over and over again? (And maybe next time, I’ll try that frakkin’ Swiss Roll milkshake. #nomnomnom)

Final Verdict: Fantastic 4-stars! 


B.J. Keeton

B.J. Keeton

B.J. is a geek, gamer, podcaster, and livestreamer. He has been the co-host of the Geek to Geek podcast since 2016, and he helped start the Geek to Geek Media Network. His biggest pet peeve is when someone spells Wookiee with only one E. One time, he told his friends he liked vegetables maybe more than he did Star Wars, and they made him put a dollar in the jar. That should tell you everything you need to know about him. Find him on Twitter as @professorbeej or on Discord as @professorbeej#1337.

Never Miss A Thing!

Sign up to never miss a podcast, blog, or geektastic giveaway.

1 Comment

  1. Tesh

    Huntsville is the one place I almost kinda sorta miss in Alabama. If I ever get a chance to go back, I’ll check this place out. Sounds like a blast!


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Subscribe to my Patreon Magazine for just $5!

press start magazine wellness issue
You can also hear more of Beej on the Geek to Geek Podcast, with a new episode every Wednesday night at 7:00pm and the Dragon Quest FM podcast every Friday morning!

He also has some really awesome sci-fi and fantasy novels that you should totally buy.


%d bloggers like this: